Below is an excerpt of the debate courtesy of the FCC and a report of the event by the SCMP Young Post.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hRbF7cIiPBo
Photos from the Grand Finals Night on the 25th September 2013 at Yew Chung International School. A report and results of the evening will be uploaded shortly.
Bronze Division Champion: Raimondi College
Silver Division Champion: Island School
Gold Division Champion: German Swiss International School
Read the rest of this entry
The first formal event under the newly reformed Hong Kong Schools Debating and Public Speaking Community concluded on Saturday the 14th at Yew Chung International School. After an absolutely stunning series of hard-fought debates, the Grand Finalists have emerged from amongst the 32 competing teams, after 5 trying debates. Over the course of the day, almost 150 debaters participated in 70 exceptional debates. After 3 preliminary rounds, teams qualified for the Gold, Silver, Bronze and Friendly Division where they faced each other in a knock-out system.
The 6 Finalists will now appear in the Grand Finals Night to be held between 5pm and 9pm on the 25th of September at Yew Chung International School to fight for the Championship prize. The Grand Finals of the three divisions are as follows:
Gold Division: 7.40pm – 8.40pm
Chinese International School (Proposition) v. German Swiss International School (Opposition)
THBT Whistleblowers Make The World Safer
Silver Division: 6.20pm – 7.20pm
La Salle College (Proposition) v. Island School (Opposition)
THW End The War On Drugs
Bronze Division: 5pm – 6pm
Shatin College (Proposition) v. Raimondi College (Opposition)
THBT Hong Kong Should Ban All Forms Of Gambling
The evening will end with a Prize Presentation Ceremony for the Champions, Runners-up and the Best Speakers of each final and of the tournament.
After 3 preliminary rounds, the 32 teams qualified for the following divisions (listed in alphabetical order). Their progress in the knock-out rounds is charted on the right. You may click on the image for a clearer (read larger) picture.
Chinese International School
Diocesan Boys School
German Swiss International School
Li Po Chun United World College
Maryknoll Convent School
St. Pauls Co-ed College
South Island School
American International School
Po Leung Kuk Ngan Po Ling College
Shun Lee Catholic Secondary School
St. Joseph College
St. Paul’s Convent School
Wah Yan College Hong Kong
Wah Yan Kowloon
Top 20 Speakers
The Top 20 speakers, based on their performance in at least 3 of first four debates (R1, R2, R3 and QF/Friendlies) are:
1. Ryan Cheng (YCIS) – 73
1. Isaac Chung (RC) – 73
3. Eleanor Yung (SPCC) – 72.5
4. Claudia Tam (IS) – 72.415
5. Tina Wong (RCHK) – 72.3333
5. Angelina Li (SC) – 72.3333
7. Alex Yeung (DBS) – 72.25
8. Aspen Wang (CIS) – 72
8. Claire Holubowskyj (DC) – 72
10. Bryan Chan (SIS) – 71.9433
11. Bianca Chan (MCS) – 71.825
12. Eliot Chen (GSIS) – 71.7766
13. Leon Chui (LSC) – 71.75
14. Bon Bong (DBS) – 71.665
14. Brian Wong (IS) – 71.665
16. Allegra Bersani (CIS) – 71.5825
16. Andrea Herman (HKIS) – 71.5825
18. Brian Lam (QC) – 71.5
19. Adrian (LPC) – 71.43333
20. Jaiwei Wang (SSGC) – 71.3333
Round 1: Impromptu released on the day
Round 2: This House would require university students to work in their country of origin for a number of years after graduation.
Round 3: This House supports the use of force to protect human rights abroad.
Round 4 will be a quarter final – impromptu motion released on the day.
Round 5 will be semi finals – motion for this debate released next week.
Day ends with 3 sets of Grand Finalists who will be given motions and sides to prepare for the Sept. 25th Grand Finals night.
World Schools Style : September 14th 2013 (preliminaries) September 25th (Grand Finals Night)
Time : 8:00am to 5:00pm – teams must arrive no later than 8.00am
Address: 3 To Fuk Road, Kowloon Tong, MTR exit D turn sharp left at exit, school entrance is 30 metres walk.
Dress Code: Formal – no school uniforms
Cost: $200 per team.
Eligibility: Senior Debaters – Years 10-13 (International Schools) / Forms 4-6 (Local Schools)
Schools can enter younger debaters at this level by prior arrangement with the tournament director.
SEPTEMBER 14th – PRELIMINARIES
Venue : Yew Chung International School
Time : 8:00am to 5:00pm
Quarter-Finals and Friendlies
The break will split the teams into 3 Divisions for the quarter finals: Positions 1- 8 Gold Quarters, positions 9-16 Silver quarters, 17-24 Bronze Quarters – all after lunch. Those teams finishing 25-32 will be paired up for friendly debates to give all debaters a chance to participate.
Pairings will be:
GOLD: 1 vs 8, 2 vs 7, 3 vs 6, 4 vs 5
SILVER: 9 vs 16, 10 vs 15, 11 vs 14, 12 vs 13
BRONZE: 17 vs 24, 18 vs 23, 19 vs 22, 20 vs 21
FRIENDLIES: pairs according to nearest finishing position
Note: this time the best speaker list will be constructed from only those who debate 3 times in the first 4 debates – we will record all speaker points for the first 4 debates – in other words only those who debate in 3 of these will be eligible for this award.
This will be an impromptu motion with 40 minutes preparation time.
The final debate of the day will be 3 levels of semi finals (12 teams involved) and the day will end with 3 sets of grand finalists determined. Teams will have 40 minutes to prepare – they can bring research material to the prep room. There will be no Grand Final on the day.
SF Motion: This House believes that tourism is bad for poor countries.
SEPTEMBER 25th – GRAND FINALS NIGHT 3 BIG DEBATES!
Venue : Yew Chung International School
Time : 5:00pm to 9:30pm
September 25th will be the night of the 3 grand finals with prepared motions to be released at the end of the 14th to the 6 finalists.
Lunch is not provided, teams must bring their own or purchase lunch from Festival Walk nearby.
Please bring your own drink bottles to fill up throughout the day.
Champions: GSIS 1
Runners-up: CIS 1
Best Speaker: Angel Cheung (GSIS 1)
Top 10 Teams
Excluding the breaking teams (CIS 1, GSIS 1, SIS and Raimondi), the teams have been ranked on the basis of the results following the three initial preliminary rounds as well as friendly debate.
- 1. [Champion] CIS 1
- 2. [Runners-up] GSIS 1
- 3. [Semi-finalist] SIS
- 4. [Semi-finalist] Raimondi
- 5. LSC – 3 wins/987 points
- 6. GSIS 2 – 3/979
- 7. CIS 2 – 3/854.5
- 8. HKIS – 2/984
- 9. AIS – 2/950.5
- 10. SPCC – 2/907.5
Top 10 Speakers
- 1. Angel Cheung (GSIS 1) 72.6
- 2. Sarika Mahbubani (RCHK) 72.5
- 2. Isaac Chung (Raimondi) 72.5
- 4. John Yap (CIS 1) 72.3
- 5. Eliot Chen (GSIS 1) 72
- 5. Jimin Kang (CIS 2) 72
- 7. Ariq Hatibie (SIS) 71.6
- 7. Andrew Kao (HKIS) 71.6
- 9. Nicholas Vallone (CIS 1) 71.5
- 9. Katrina Chu (KGV) 71.5
Round 1: Impromptu, Motion
Round 2: This House believes that the United States has done more good than harm to the rest of the world.
Round 3: This house believes that governments should use economic methods to encourage healthy behavior.
SF/Friendlies: Impromptu Motion
Grand Final: : This house believes that individuals who make damaging comments on social media should face prosecution.
In the draw below, the team mentioned first in each contest is the proposition and the team second is opposition.
|Round 1||Round 2||Round 3|
|CNDIS (Prop) vs CIS 2 (Opp)||KGV (Prop) vs QES (Opp)||Raimondi (Prop) vs STC (Opp)|
|GSIS 1 vs LSC||HKIS vs GSIS 1||GSIS 1 vs CIS 2|
|AIS vs SIS||SIS vs CNDIS||RC vs SIS|
|SPCC vs HKIS||LSC vs SPCC||SPCC vs GSIS 2|
|CIS 1 vs QES||GSIS 2 vs CIS 1||CIS 1 vs AIS|
|RC vs QC||CIS 2 vs RC||SSGC vs QC|
|SSGC vs GSIS 2||AIS vs IS||IS vs HKIS|
|Raimondi vs KGV||STC vs SSGC||CNDIS vs KGV|
|IS vs STC||QC vs Raimondi||QES vs LSC|
Read the rest of this entry